Published on:

Sometimes Having Insurance isn’t Enough

Just because you have insurance doesn’t mean that you’re protected.

Sometimes the insurance you have isn’t the right type of insurance, or doesn’t cover you for the full extent of your losses.

As the title to this edition of the Toronto Injury Lawyer Blog Post indicates: Sometimes Having Insurance just isn’t Enough.

A small business owner approached our law firm last week. There was a flood at his warehouse. The flood came from a sprinkler system which accidentally went off overnight. When the business owner returned to open shop that morning, all of his inventory was soaking wet and destroyed. Nothing could be done to salvage the wet inventory which has been soaked overnight under the active sprinklers. He didn’t have an automatic sprinkler shut off valve which might have saved his inventory. The good news is that the small business owner has business interruption insurance. The bad news is that the business interruption insurance did not cover him for a few reasons in these circumstances.

Reason #1 You Purchased The Wrong Coverage

The coverage the business owner had did not apply to any of his inventory. Rather, it applied in the event that he was not able to operate his business from his insured premises; which in this case was his warehouse. The flood only damaged the inventory. It didn’t cause any structural damage to the warehouse. The warehouse remained operational and people were able to work the day after the flood. In the event that business could not run out of the warehouse, then the insurance coverage would take effect. But, the insurance specifically did NOT cover damage to any of his goods. In this case, he had the wrong coverage, or coverage which did not meet his needs.

Reason #2 You Purchased the Right Coverage, but Not Enough of it

Let’s assume for a second that the insurance applied to damaged goods. The value of the goods which were damaged in the flood was $100,000. But, the insurance coverage only covered a maximum of $50,000 per insurable event. In this case, the business owner would be redeemed up to the policy limits of $50,000; but he would still be out the remaining $50,000 because he didn’t purchase enough coverage.linkedin-2-300x300

Reason #3 The Exclusions in Your Policy can Kill Your Claim

The damage to the merchandise was caused by a faulty sprinkler system which went off in the middle of the night and caused a flood.  One of the exclusions contained in the insurance policy is that there are no insurable losses if the damage is caused by flooding due to internal leaks or malfunctions. The sprinkler malfunction would fall under this set of exclusions and accordingly, would result in the small business owner’s claim failing. The devil’s in the details for these types of claims. It’s best to know what claims would be successful, and what claims won’t. Simply having insurance doesn’t mean that you’re covered. Not all insurance policies are created equal.

Reason #4 Hidden Detail Requirements in order to have a Successful Claim

People pay lawyers to sort over the fine print in contracts. Insurance policies are contracts, just like any other. It’s those details which can make, or break a successful claim. Under most policies, there are hidden details which are important. Some of those hidden details are requirements for a policy holder to have an automatic water shut off valve; or time limitations on when to give notice about a claim. Failure to hit these marks can mean that the claim will fail even before it gets off the ground. One of the most common things we see at Goldfinger Injury Lawyers are people failing to give notice of an insurance claim within the time stipulated under the policy. Your policy might have wording requiring that you give notice of a claim or damage within 48 hours of the damage taking place. Sometimes the insurance company is the last party which people contact. Waiting to report a claim isn’t a wise strategy. An otherwise meritorious claim can be rejected should you delay in reporting it. In addition, there are usually benefits to reporting a claim right away. Under many policies there is coverage for emergency remediation services. The insurer would pay for a team to come on site to repair any damage, or clean up any mess that needs to be addressed right away; regardless or the merits of the claim itself.

Reason #5 You lied, or didn’t fully disclose your business operations to the insurance company

This happens more than you might think. In our case, the small business owner sold light bulbs and light fixtures. He told the insurance company exactly that. Fair. But, what the business owner didn’t disclose is that he also sold cheese, wine, fruit and other perishable goods. This is a different story for the insurer and involves a separate set of calculations and variables when determining policy premiums and coverage. Another example of this is car insurance. You buy regular consumer car insurance. But, you also use your car to drive Uber or Lyft. You don’t disclose to the insurance company that you’re using your vehicle for commercial ride sharing. If the insurer would know that, they would likely charge you at a different set of rates for your premiums. Different coverage would have been offered as well (consumer coverage vs. commercial coverage).

Conclusion

There is no “perfect” insurance policy or perfect insurance solution. But, there are certainly wrong forms of coverage which will get you nowhere fast. Making sure that you aren’t in the boat with the wrong coverage is a good starting point. Ruling out the wrong forms of coverage will bring you one step closer to a form of insurance coverage that’s right for you. It won’t be perfect. And there will be some things about the policy that you won’t like or won’t agree with. But, that’s a better start than having a policy which stands no chance of meeting your needs. Rule out the bad policies to get to a better policy which stands a fighting chance of getting you compensated in the event of that rainy day.

Contact Information